Table of Contents

In criminal law, the concept of competency plays a crucial role in ensuring that the legal proceedings are fair and just. This legal term refers to a defendant’s ability to understand the charges against them and participate adequately in their defense. Assessing competency is a fundamental aspect of the criminal justice process, as it affects the core principles of due process and the right to a fair trial.

Understanding Competency

Competency primarily concerns a defendant’s mental state and their ability to engage with the court system. It involves determining whether a defendant can comprehend the nature of the proceedings, the potential consequences, and effectively communicate with their attorney to assist in their defense strategy. This assessment is crucial, as proceeding with a criminal case against a defendant who is found incompetent violates fundamental legal standards.

Legal Standards for Assessing Competency

The standard for determining competency was established in the landmark case Dusky v. United States (1960), which requires that defendants have a rational and factual understanding of the proceedings against them, and the ability to consult with their lawyer with a reasonable degree of rational understanding. If doubts about a defendant’s competency arise, a psychological evaluation is typically ordered, and a hearing may be held to assess the individual’s mental fitness.

The Role of Psychological Evaluations

Psychological evaluations in determining competency involve a thorough assessment by forensic psychologists or psychiatrists. These professionals examine the defendant’s mental condition through interviews, behavioral observations, and various psychological tests. The findings are then reported to the court, which uses this information to make a judgment on the defendant’s fitness to proceed with trial.


The Impact of Competency on Criminal Proceedings

If a defendant is found incompetent, the criminal proceedings are generally halted. The court may order hospitalization or treatment aimed at restoring the defendant’s competency. Only once competency is established can the legal process continue. This safeguard protects the defendant’s right to participate in their defense and ensures that the trial is conducted fairly.

How Boatwright Legal Handles Competency Issues

Boatwright Legal is proficient in addressing issues related to a defendant’s competency. The firm’s attorneys are experienced in recognizing signs of potential incompetency and taking appropriate legal action. They work closely with medical experts to evaluate their clients and provide compelling arguments during competency hearings. Their proactive approach ensures that the rights of the accused are protected throughout the legal process.

Ethical and Human Rights Considerations

Dealing with competency in criminal defense raises significant ethical and human rights considerations. It is essential to balance the state’s interest in prosecuting criminal behavior with the need to treat mentally ill or incapacitated defendants with dignity and fairness. Boatwright Legal adheres to the highest ethical standards, advocating for the proper treatment and evaluation of their clients, and ensuring that justice is served without compromising the well-being of those who are not fully capable of defending themselves.

Challenges in Competency Cases

One of the main challenges in handling competency issues is the subjective nature of mental health evaluations and the variability in expert opinions. Additionally, restoring a defendant to competency can be a complex and lengthy process, involving psychiatric treatment and ongoing assessments. Boatwright Legal navigates these challenges by maintaining a network of reputable experts and staying informed about the latest developments in forensic psychology.


Competency is a cornerstone of a fair criminal justice system, ensuring that only those who are capable of understanding and participating in their defense are subjected to trial. Boatwright Legal’s commitment to rigorously addressing competency issues reflects their dedication to upholding the rights and dignity of their clients. By ensuring that competency evaluations are conducted thoroughly and ethically, they help maintain the integrity of the legal process and safeguard the foundational principles of justice for all individuals, regardless of their mental state.

Enlist An Experienced Criminal Defense Lawyer Today!

If you or somebody close to you has been accused or is being investigated for murder, drug crimes, theft, burglary, or assault and battery, the lawyer you hire to safeguard your rights may prove to be the difference between incarceration and freedom. To learn more about what your legal options are in your charge, make sure to consult with a skilled criminal defense lawyer right away. Remember that your freedom is on the line here. Contact Boatwright Legal at 864-745-9758 now to schedule a case evaluation.

Read Our Blog

Piedmont Natural Gas Downtown Alive in Greenville, South Carolina

Piedmont Natural Gas Downtown Alive

Looking for the perfect way to unwind after a long week? Look no further than Piedmont Natural Gas Downtown Alive! This exciting event, happening every Thursday night from March 14

Read More »
burglary vs robbery in South Carolina

Robbery vs Burglary: What Is the Difference?

People may assume that “burglary” and “robbery” are interchangeable terms. However, a Greenville defense attorney understands they are different. It’s not uncommon for someone to be charged with robbery and

Read More »